How Do I Judge a Test Prep Course?

From "College Times 2000/2001"

What gain should you expect from coaching? College Board research says coached students gain an average of 69 points on the verbal and math parts of the SAT combined. But students who are not coached gain an average of 43 points when they take an SAT a second time (which is why it's a good idea to take the test more than once). Since 69 - 43 = 26, the coaching itself accounts for an average of 26 points.

What to look for in a test prep course? We asked longtime California high school counselors Carolyn Barnhart and Joanne Domenici. (Joanne is also a former test prep instructor.) They urged students to beware the fly-by-night courses. Go for respected names and known organizations, and look at the quality of instructors. Joanne says, "You want an instructor who captures your attention. Getting totally bored for hours isn't going to help you." Try to check out the instructor's credentials: Are they trained, experienced teachers who know how to teach?

Avoid organizations that prey on test anxiety, getting you to pay lots of money for lots of test prep. A course should last about 20 hours- beyond that, you'll still gain test points, but, on average, fewer and fewer points for every hour of coaching. Ask yourself: Will my college application benefit more if I spend 30 hours as, say, a hospital volunteer, or if I take another 30 hours of coaching and gain 12 points on the SAT?

Finally, avoid outfits that "over-promise." If a course claims to raise scores by an average of 100 points, look out. Fact: Only about 12% of coached students improve their verbal scores by 100 points, 8 % of uncoached students achieve the same gain. In general, studies show that coaching has a greater effect on the math than on the verbal part of the test.